Best Restaurants in Skaneateles
Skaneateles, a picturesque village nestled in the Finger Lakes region of New York, is not just known for its stunning lake views and charming boutiques, but also for its vibrant dining scene. From cozy bistros to elegant fine dining establishments, Skaneateles offers a variety of culinary experiences that cater to every palate. Whether you're a local foodie or a tourist seeking a memorable meal, this guide to the best restaurants in Skaneateles will help you navigate the town's gastronomic landscape. Each restaurant listed here has been carefully selected based on its menu, ambiance, service, and most importantly, the quality and taste of its dishes. So, prepare your taste buds for a delightful journey through Skaneateles' top dining spots.
Joelle's french bistro
4.8
(87)
Reviews:
A hidden GEM! I can’t believe it took us 2 years to find this restaurant just outside Skaneateles. One of the best dining experiences we’ve had in a very long time. Unmatched service, superb and unique cuisine that was totally unexpected. We dined on the back patio and it was simply perfect! Highly recommend!
RCS Ltd
It's easy to rate Joelle's at 5☆! The food was amazing!! The appetizers were beautiful and delicious. The salad with boursin in a purse, and the mushroom soup were outstanding. We loved the shrimp dish and the halibut. We all shared a perfect flaming crème brûlée. I suspect anything on the menu would be excellent. The service was super friendly. The atmosphere was great!! Enjoy!!!
Clifford Ehrlich
Great outdoor seating on the deck, food was delish, and staff was very attentive. Truly authentic fare.
Greg Doyle
Great date night dinner! Always a warm, friendly atmosphere! We usually call for reservations and request the outside patio if the forecast looks good. It does get a little "buggy" as the sun goes down. They have bug spray or bring your own. Hey it's CNY! Full drink selection with French wines of course! The gourmet menu is on par, next to none, and consistent year after year (we have been coming here since 2012ish) from the appetizers to entrees ending with their desserts. A must try for decerning palates. Pricing is right for drinks, food, and ambience. There were some families there with children, wanted to add that in to let you know it not a "stuffy" establishment!
Timothy Kiser
Food and the view was perfect! We especially enjoyed appetizers(oyster and onion soup).
Young
4423 State St, Skaneateles, NY 13152, USA
Lakehouse pub
4.6
(665)
Rustic, laid-back hangout featuring classic eats & draft beer, plus regular live music.
Reviews:
From out of state and a local buddy of mine showed me this place. Great little place to grab a drink with friends. Plus, I heard they have a band play on certain days and they are pretty good too. Will be coming back when I'm local again.
Kyle Saren
Definitely thee best Beef on Weck I've ever had!
CYNTHIA HARDING
Fun llittle pub with great bites. Warm and inviting space with friendly service. I enjoyed the Pub Salad and my husband enjoyed the fried shrimp tacos for lunc.. We both enjoyed our food and would definitely come back.
Kimberly Giang
The food for everyone in my party was great and the staff was friendly! However, avoid the nachos at all costs. They were not made with nacho cheese, but colby jack. I’m pretty sure they were microwaved to melt the cheese too. So everything ended up hard and dry, I really wish I’d gotten something else!
Robert Bush
Beef on a wick with horseradish sauce and au jus "French dip".Just like I remembered growing up visiting Buffalo New York. Service excellent. Price excellent. My friend that usually eats like a bird ate every bite ...me too ... What a hidden gem 💎 ✨️ 👏
Irene Wilson
6 W Genesee St, Skaneateles, NY 13152, USA
Good eats & sips
4.8
(104)
Reviews:
GOOD eats & sips has delicious food and plant based meals! We visited from Chicago for a wedding. We found ourselves here everyday! We LOVE Marie's Noodle Bowl, Emma's Smoothie Bowl, Mike's Smoothie Bowl and Gaby's Vegan Cobb! We also loved their lattes that were made perfectly! The staff and Marie are very friendly and professional. Well worth the visit!!
M Kahle
This place is great! Located right across from the lake and docks you can grab your coffee, bagel, smoothie for breakfast or a wide variety of good and good for you lunch spot. Service is friendly and food comes out quickly, even when busy. Skip the long lines down the block and load up here. Alex bowl is probably named after me. 😉
Alex Porter
This place is adorable! The ambiance is modern and cozy, and the food lives up to its name. Kate was attentive and hospitable 💗. We enjoyed our visit here 😀
Carrie Natale
So delicious! Loved all of the healthy options and great variety of toppings for the bowls. My chai matcha latte was perfect. I even purchased extra protein bites and granola to take home for later. Would definitely recommend eating here!
Kimberly Giang
Good light fare or filling grains this place is a nice respite from the usual heavy meals in the area. Yes. I'd recommend it for many. Relaxing atmosphere. Forgot to take the picture before eating. But the plate shows how good the meal was. Yum.
David Stuck
18 W Genesee St, Skaneateles, NY 13152, USA
The krebs
4.6
(384)
Founded in 1899, this elevated dining fixture offers farm-to-fork American cuisine & a full bar.
Reviews:
By far the best food we had at the finger lakes. We stayed for 3 days and I will absolutely come back here on the next visit. The lobster Benedict was amazing. Cocktails were great too! Service is very friendly and accommodating.
Justin Bowers
My husband opted to make reservations for our 5th Wedding Anniversary. I was surprised since this is not the type of place we usually patron. I mean it's more upscale but he wanted to try a fine dining restaurant. First place I've ever been where the silverware is changed before your meal. The food was excellent. The staff was very attentive and welcoming. I had the krebs burger and my husband had the tenderloin, which was $60. Although it was one of the best tenderloin he's ever had.
NICOLE NILES
Food is good with a nice relaxing atmosphere. There was a good selection on their menu with options that are different than what you will find in the area. The wait staff were nice and accommodating. Parking can be difficult, you may have to park along the road if it's too busy. The patrons can be pretty stuffy/Karen-y but I knew this going in but the nice wait staff make up for it. Would go again for sure!
Trish L.
Let me just say perfect across the board. My husband and I enjoyed a wonderful brunch here. The atmosphere is amazing! It’s a combination of understated elegance and old world charm. Our waiter was extremely friendly and attentive, food was fresh and delicious. We are looking forward to returning for dinner.
Carol Corcoran
Very romantic atmosphere. Service was great. Our waiter was Antonio and he was very helpful with recommendations and attentive. The hostess was accommodating and took photos for us. Everyone wished my husband a happy birthday. Oh and the drinks were good! Definitely recommending the Mary
Lafania Madera
53 W Genesee St, Skaneateles, NY 13152, USA
Blue water grill
4.3
(1368)
Friendly American grill includes breakfast & sushi menus, plus TVs at the bar & a lakefront deck.
Reviews:
We love the lobster roll, and the fries are quite good. They can be busy and don't take reservations for parties of less than six. But, they will take your cell phone number when you arrive and text you when your table's ready. This allows you time to visit some of the nearby boutiques, or explore the pier and lakeside park. With all the windows in their dining rooms, it can get pretty warm and stuffy on a sunny day. If available, I recommend a table on the outside patio. The service is excellent. UPDATE: We returned on a Thursday for lunch and, although it was the peak of the tourist season, we were seated at one of the 7 tables on the outdoor patio within 5 minutes. I very much enjoyed the shrimp po' boy tacos with the optional addition of taco chips and pico de gallo. The remoulade sauce on the fried shrimp was an excellent pairing, and the tomato salsa with the chips had a pronounced cilantro aroma and tasted as if it had just been prepared.
N N
Needed a place to grab a bite and kill some time. The wait was over an hour but we took seats at the back bar that had no wait. Service and food were exceptional. Very reasonably priced for a 'touristy' town. Great value. Would definitely come back.
Sarah Eldred
Was surprised I didn’t see any reviews of the English Pub curry. It was terrific! Basically your typical Indian style tikka masala. Mild to slightly spicy. Very creamy mild tomato sauce. Rice and naan were soft and complimented everything nicely. Great choice if you’re interested in something outside the norm.
tom
Excellent grill and diner on the lakefront in Skaneatles. Good quality food and nice atmosphere.
Csaba Csaki
Very good restaurant, overlooking the lake. Good food, good drinks and very nice service. Recommended!!
Gianluca Manzoni
11 W Genesee St, Skaneateles, NY 13152, USA
Valentine's delicatessen
4.6
(241)
Reviews:
Pizza was overall really great and well priced. Many different types of "by the slice" were ready to eat. I would give their cheese pizza a 3 star, as the sauce or cheese needs a kick but the 3 Cheese Chipotle Chicken pizza was a 4.5 star, as the crust and toppings were in perfect harmony. This place is worth a visit if you love pizza. The staff was very friendly too.
Ryan Sanderson
The service was superb and the pizza is to die for. I recommend the sausage & pepperoni, buffalo wing, and waffle fries. I will definitely be back 🤗🤤
Jessica Fernandez
I love valentines for me it’s the last thing that makes this town what it is I been getting pizza here my whole life and hope I can continue to for many more years some of the best pizza I’ve had in NY. Staff is very nice and the inside has a good atmosphere and is nostalgic to me and they always have slices available. Only problem if any is parking but what can you do. I hope they continue to do the amazing job that they have been doing.
Zac
I moved to Skaneateles from Ohio recently. I'm a guy who feels that home isn't quite "Home" until one has found a blistering local pizza joint. Well, I've found it. Valentine's is dynamite. The pizza is excellent (I recommend the extra-baked option, but suture yourself), and so are the wraps. The wing sauce is also top notch, and the heat ratings are pretty accurate; if you order wings extra wet/saucy, they'll come out absolutely swimming, which is just a beautiful thing. The service is fast, and even with my annoying habit for customization, they've messed up exactly ZERO of the things I've ordered over numerous weekends. Highly recommend.
Derrick Niese
Ordered a large pizza July 4th evening... it was absolutely delicious and cooked perfectly! Not surprised since we always have delicious meals there. Excellent end to an amazing holiday weekend... Thanks Valentine's!
Midlakes Navigation
18 W Genesee St, Skaneateles, NY 13152, USA
Rosalie's cucina
4.6
(617)
Hearty Italian food served in a Tuscan-style space plus a bakery serving pastries & pizzas to go.
Reviews:
Waited over an hour to be served from the time we ordered and one of our meals was so overcooked and dry, we couldn't eat it. The mushroom orzo dish was fine but not great either. They handled it very well though which we appreciated. And I will say their bread was spectacular.
Joanie Axelbaum
My husband and I went for the first time and the food was amazing! Leslie our server was a gem. She was very attentive of our needs. I had the lobster and it was very good. We will definitely go back.
Magikal Ways
Fantastic experience! The food was fabulous! The ambiance was cozy and romantic. The waitress was awesome!
Jeanette Durkin
An old favorite we hadn't visited in awhile & it was as great as ever. Cozy, great waitress Theresa, and the food, SO good! Such attention to details & upscale but with prices the same as most places, but here it's kicked up a notch. Staff is friendly, attentive & work well with each other. Such a treasure in the FLX.
Holly Mosher
It’s so wonderful to be greeted at the door! If we don’t have a reservation we enjoy eating at the bar. The bartenders are fantastic and will always make sure your drink is perfect. The food is superb and always consistent. Highly recommend Rosalie’s!
Mary
841 W Genesee Street Rd, Skaneateles, NY 13152, USA